CBSE Class 9 English NCERT Solutions: If I Were You
CBSE Class 9 English, Chapter 11, 'If I Were You' presents a compelling drama of wit and deception. This play explores the tense encounter between a clever playwright, Gerrard, and an intruder who plans to take his identity. The NCERT Solutions delve into the intricacies of this conflict, explaining Gerrard's sharp intellect and the intruder's desperate scheme. We examine the motivations behind each character's actions, the significance of their dialogue, and how Gerrard masterfully turns the tables on his adversary. The solutions also touch upon Gerrard's profession, highlighting how his creativity and quick thinking are central to the play's resolution. Understanding these elements will equip students with a deeper appreciation of the text and aid in their exam preparation by providing clear, insightful analyses of the play's dramatic tension and thematic depth.
Quick info
| Board | CBSE |
|---|---|
| Class | Class 9 |
| Subject | English |
| Session | 2026 |
| Language | English |
| Type | NCERT Solutions |
| Chapter | 11. If I Were You |
Chapter summary
This chapter's NCERT Solutions for CBSE Class 9 English, 'If I Were You', focuses on analyzing the dramatic text. It addresses questions related to the plot, including the intruder's failed attempt to impersonate Gerrard, and explores character motivations. Key dialogues are explained, and Gerrard's profession as a playwright is highlighted with supporting evidence from the text. The solutions aim to enhance comprehension of the play's suspenseful narrative and its underlying themes.
Learning outcomes
- Understand the plot and character motivations in 'If I Were You'.
- Analyze the significance of key dialogues and dramatic irony.
- Identify Gerrard's profession and the textual evidence supporting it.
- Explain the intruder's plan and the reasons for its failure.
- Interpret the play's themes of identity and deception.
Topics covered
Paper topics
- Plot Summary of 'If I Were You'
- Character Analysis: Gerrard
- Character Analysis: The Intruder
- Themes: Identity and Deception
- Dramatic Irony
- Dialogue Analysis
- Gerrard's Profession
- Intruder's Motives
- The Play's Climax and Resolution
- Understanding Sarcasm in Dialogue
Important topics
- Gerrard's cleverness in outsmarting the intruder
- The intruder's plan and its failure
- Analysis of key dialogues
- Gerrard's profession as a playwright
- Themes of identity and impersonation
PDF preview
Read page by page below. PDF is streamed from the official NCERT website — no download button on this page.
Questions and Solutions
Question 1
The following words and phrases occur in the play. Do you know their meanings? Match them with the meanings given, to find out.
cultured an informal expression for a fashionable vehicle count on unnecessary and usually harmful
No, the intruder does not succeed in his plan to murder Gerrard and take on his identity. Gerrard, through his quick thinking and clever manipulation, manages to outwit the intruder. Instead of being a victim, Gerrard turns the tables on the intruder, leading to the intruder's downfall.
The meanings of the words and phrases are as follows:
- cultured: sophisticated; well-mannered
- count on: depend on; rely on
- engaged: occupied; busy
- melodramatic: exaggerated
- wise guy: to be smart (American English); an informal way of saying that one is being too clever
- inflection: here, a tone of voice
Question 2
(i) Who says this?
(ii) Why does he say it?
(iii) Is he sarcastic or serious?
(i) Gerrard says this line.
(ii) He says this because the intruder has just entered his cottage and is questioning him, demanding to know about his life. Gerrard feels that he is finally getting an audience, albeit an unwilling and dangerous one, to listen to him.
(iii) Gerrard speaks this dialogue sarcastically. He is not genuinely pleased to have an audience; rather, he is using irony to comment on the intruder's aggressive questioning and the dangerous situation he finds himself in.
Question 3
The intruder chooses Gerrard as the person whose identity he wants to take on primarily because they are of similar physical build. This similarity in appearance is crucial for the intruder's plan to successfully impersonate Gerrard and evade the police.
Question 4
(i) Who says this?
(ii) What does it mean?
(iii) Is it the truth? What is the speaker's reason for saying this?
(i) Gerrard says this line.
(ii) This statement implies that Gerrard has a history of using violence, specifically shooting people, to escape dangerous situations. It suggests he is a man of action who deals with problems decisively.
(iii) No, this is not the truth. Gerrard is fabricating this story to mislead the intruder. His reason for saying this is to make himself appear more dangerous and perhaps like a criminal himself, thereby impressing or intimidating the intruder and gaining an advantage in their confrontation. He wants to make the intruder believe he is capable of violence and might be a difficult target.
Question 5
Gerrard is a playwright by profession. Several parts of the play strongly suggest this profession:
- His comment, "This is all very melodramatic, not very original, perhaps, but..." shows his critical eye for dramatic presentation.
- The line, "At last a sympathetic audience!" can be interpreted as a playwright's remark about his situation.
- He remarks, "In most melodramas the villain is foolish enough to delay his killing long enough to be frustrated", indicating his familiarity with dramatic conventions.
- He also says, "I said, you were luckier than most melodramatic villains," further referencing the genre.
- His mention of "That's a disguise outfit; false moustaches and what not" points to stage props.
- Most tellingly, he says, "Sorry I can't let you have the props in time for rehearsal, I've had a spot of bother - quite amusing. I think I'll put it in my next play." This directly confirms his profession as a writer of plays.
Question 6
(i) Who says this?
(ii) Why does the speaker say it?
(iii) What according to the speaker will stop Gerrard from being smart?
(i) The intruder says this line to Gerrard.
(ii) The intruder says this because he is annoyed by Gerrard's calm and witty responses, which he perceives as 'smartness'. He feels Gerrard is not taking the situation seriously enough and is trying to be clever, which irritates him.
(iii) According to the speaker (the intruder), Gerrard will stop being smart once he understands the gravity of the situation and the intruder's deadly intentions. The intruder believes that facing the reality of being murdered and having his identity stolen will strip away Gerrard's clever facade and make him fearful and subdued.
Common mistakes
- Misinterpreting the intruder's motives.
- Failing to recognize Gerrard's cleverness in manipulating the situation.
- Confusing the literal meaning of dialogues with their intended dramatic effect.
- Overlooking the importance of Gerrard's profession in understanding his actions.
Revision tips
- Reread the play, paying close attention to Gerrard's dialogue and actions.
- Summarize the plot in your own words, focusing on the turning points.
- Analyze the character of the intruder and his weaknesses.
- Discuss the play's ending and its implications with classmates.
Practice MCQs
Q1. What is the primary reason the intruder chooses Gerrard's identity to assume?
Explanation: The intruder specifically mentions that Gerrard is of a similar build, which is crucial for successfully impersonating someone.
Q2. Who says, 'At last a sympathetic audience.'?
Explanation: Gerrard says this line sarcastically to the intruder, who is demanding to hear about Gerrard's life.
Q3. What does Gerrard mean when he says, 'I said it with bullets.'?
Explanation: Gerrard is lying to the intruder, fabricating a past incident where he used a gun to escape, to make himself seem more dangerous and experienced.
Q4. What is Gerrard's profession?
Explanation: Gerrard's dialogue, referencing melodramas, rehearsals, and putting events into his next play, strongly suggests he is a playwright.
Q5. Why does the intruder's plan ultimately fail?
Explanation: Gerrard cleverly manipulates the situation, using his intelligence and acting skills to trick the intruder into revealing himself and ultimately leading to his downfall.
Frequently asked questions
What is the main conflict in the play 'If I Were You'?
The main conflict is between Gerrard and the intruder. The intruder plans to murder Gerrard and assume his identity, while Gerrard uses his wit to foil the intruder's plan.
Why does the intruder want to take on Gerrard's identity?
The intruder, who is a criminal on the run, wants to take on Gerrard's identity because they are of similar build, and he believes Gerrard's quiet life will allow him to escape the law.
How does Gerrard manage to defeat the intruder?
Gerrard uses his intelligence and acting skills. He deceives the intruder by pretending to be a criminal himself and by making the intruder believe that killing him would be a foolish mistake, leading the intruder into a trap.
What does Gerrard's profession as a playwright reveal about him?
His profession as a playwright suggests he is imaginative, quick-witted, and skilled at creating and improvising narratives, which he uses effectively to manipulate the intruder.
Is the ending of 'If I Were You' happy?
The ending is generally considered a victory for Gerrard, as he successfully outsmarts and neutralizes the threat posed by the intruder, thus saving himself. The intruder's fate is sealed by his own actions.
Content reviewed by the NCERT Help team. Editorial Team and update policy
NCERT Solutions PDF PDF on NCERT Help. URL unchanged for search indexing.